As
can be seen from the previous examples, the maxims of CP are often
conventionally suppressed in favour of maintaining the ´social equilibrium´
which may be just as important as the cooperation itself (it may even be more
important as in white lies, i.e., minor,
polite, or harmless lies). The need not to cause any damage to and to uphold
each others´ face (e.g., not criticizing
the quality of service or food in the restaurant directly) is the central
problem of the theories of politeness. G. Leech (1983) proposes the six maxims
of Politeness Principle (PP) as a way of complementing the CP and thus ´rescuing´
it from serious ´trouble´ (i.e., accounting for the situations when a strict
adherence to CP would be unacceptable):
tact, generosity, approbation, modesty, agreement, sympathy. The tact maxim regulates the operation of the
directive speech acts (which are marked with highest face-threatening
potential) and addresses the dominant type of politeness which, with regard to
the addressee, can be ´measured´ on the
cost-benefit scale: the more costly an action, the less polite it is,
and, conversely, the more beneficial it is to the addressee, the more polite it
is. This helps explain why, for example, imperative mood is not necessarily
associated with impoliteness: Bring me some water vs. Have another drink. Next,
optionality scale is used to rank options according to the degree of choice
offered to the addressee - the degree of politeness matches the degree of
indirectness (tentativeness), and, vice versa, increased directness results in
greater impoliteness (e.g., Lend me your car vs. Do you think you could
possibly lend me your car?). It appears that while imperatives offer little
option of whether or not to comply with
the action requested (Give me some change), questions (Have you got a quarter,
by any chance?), hypothetical formulations (Could I borrow some money?), and
ones using negatives (You couldn´t lend me a dollar, could you?) provide
greater freedom to deny that request. Of course, politeness formulae (please)
can always be added to give extra politeness. We should also differentiate between absolute and
relative politeness; in the absolute sense, Lend me your car is less
polite than I hope you don´t mind my
asking, but I wonder if it might be at all possible for you to lend me your
car. However, in some situations, the former request could be overpolite (among
family members) and the latter one impolite (as an ironic remark).
Комментариев нет:
Отправить комментарий